Consensus and Controversy

It is refreshing to take part in a discussion about national ID systems that -- unlike most discussions  of this topic -- is not dominated by hysteria.

Here are a few propositions that I think might form a basis for going forward in reasoned debate.  (I of course welcome debate on the accuracy of these propositions as well as the conclusions that might flow from them)

Base propositions:

1.  A national ID is not the magic bullet that will make the country safe from terrorism.   Given the very poor controls we have on birth certificates at home (not to mention the impossibility of relying on the quality control foreign credentials) it at most it creates a speedbump for foreign terrorists who will need to get phony versions of the credentials used as the basis for issuing the US ID.

2.  A national ID system cannot secure our borders.

3.  A national ID system can, however, assist in making illegal immigration more unpleasant for immigrants by, for example, making it more difficult to employ them.   All other things being equal, this should reduce the incentive for that part of illegal immigration driven primarily by economic considerations.

4. More generally, a national ID system has some substantial potential to be the cornerstone of a national fraud-prevention system.   

5. A national ID system potentially creates new avenues for super-fraud and highly effective identity theft.

6. A national ID system potentially creates new avenues for governmental dossier creation on all citizens who use the national ID.  These opportunities exist even if the system is not misused, and are greater if it is misused.  As Lee Tien put it "'national ID' is not a card, but an entire system of databases, information gathering activities, and human beings making fateful judgments about individuals based on that overall system."

7.  A National Research Council report ("Who Goes There -- Authentication Through the Lens of Privacy") noted this:

Finding 6.5: State-issued driver's licenses are a de facto nationwide identity system. They are widely accepted for transactions that require a  form of government-issued photo ID.

Real ID substantially increases the likelihood that driver's licenses will become a defacto national ID for an even greater range of offline and online transactions.

8.  The extent to which we reap the costs and benefits listed above is very sensitive to how the system is actually implemented.   For example, a well-implemented biometric identifier makes fraud and identity theft more difficult, but also makes it more devastating when it happens since people become more reliant on the ID's security (and it is hard to grow a new retina).

Am I correct that the above propositions are (in the abstract) uncontroversial, and the controversy is in fact about how big and how likely the positive and negative effects are, and how they compare to each other?

Or, as Dan Combs put it in his contribution,

1. REAlID done right = good

2. RealID done wrong = very bad

3. The bar is high for such a system to be good.

        We aren't close yet!

I will add the following personal observations, which I suspect might be more controversial than the above:

I.   For any ID system to be implemented competently (let alone in a fashion that inspires trust) supervisory authority must be taken out of the hapless Department of Homeland Security.

II.  For Real ID to be implemented competently it must have federal funding rather than being left to the states as an unfunded mandate.

III.  Real ID driver's licenses are likely to become a de facto national ID -- much more than current driver's licenses -- not just because of the federal pressure driven by national security needs (or rhetoric) but also because of commercial pressure from a variety of industries.

IV. The ID must be transparent -- end users must be able to read everything coded on the ID itself. 

V.  If we are going to have a real or de facto national ID card, all citizens must have a right to review and correct information held on them in both public and private dossiers linked to the ID.

(For more about what I think, see my paper, The Uneasy Case for National ID Cards.)

Comments

[Wade]

Do you have a spam problem on this blog; I also am a blogger, and I was wondering your situation; many of us have developed some nice methods and we are looking to exchange methods with other folks, be sure
to shoot me an e-mail if interested.

[Flollaquawl]

north face outlet Has multiple different design north face coats concept of Supreme in north face sale perfect of with north face jackets into has variety of design north face outlet element Hou, in this north face sale quarter of fall/winter concept in the north face sale still build has north face uk series of Mountain Shell Jacket アグ jacket and the Medium Day Pack Backpack ugg ブーツ Backpack series, and is ugg ブーツ 2012 different from Yu spring summer season to map for concept of camouflage design, this north face clothing repeatedly used has relative simplicity of design, mix north face sale Shang The North Face excellent function cold design, Absolute north face online guarantee that we will, in this year's autumn and winter on both the warmth and the mix is in north face uk perfect condition

[fitting anti wrinkle creams website]

Very interesting topics here in your site mate. Can't wait to read more of your blogs. Just keep it coming.

[click to check what Extenze is all about]

Very interesting topics here in your site Mary Frantz. A complete and clear review.Can't wait to read more of your blogs.Just keep it coming. :)

[Poker Gratis Geld]

Guten Tag wahrhaft haarlocke flügel meine Wenigkeit bin da ehrlich oft des Weiteren verbinge
eine betrag dauer in diesem Zusammenhang gen deiner
rand weiter auf diese Weise. Poker Gratis Geld

[Bonus Ohne Einzahlung Poker]

Great article and very interesting blog. That's one thing I'm really looking forward. Looking forward to reading more from you.

[Bonus Senza Deposito Poker]

This is fantastic information for blog. I really love the way infomration presented in your post. I have added to you in my social bookmark…and i am w8ing ur next post.

[Pokermaniaq Bonus]

You guys must have SOME idea of a timeframe for things getting back online. Even if you think it’s going to be weeks, months, whatever, give us something here.

[Free Poker Money]

Thanks for the update. Even though I know there probably isn’t much to say, it’s good that you’re checking in here to talk to the masses.

[Instant Poker Money]

Well I hope the rebuilding of your network also helps make certain things on the PSN quicker (looking at profiles and comparing trophies for example). First and foremost though, just do whats needed to get secure and get the system up and running.

[Poker za Free]

Thanks for the update, but i believe what everyone wants to know is wheter credit card info and the money already in our accounts was compromised at any point.

[Bonus Poker Online]

Thanks for posting. At least we know that you don’t know anything (though most people will find it hard to believe that YOU don’t know anything).

[Bonus Ohne Einzahlung]

I think this site is very interesting, and will frequent often from home and work. Your page is looking really nice-Well thought out!

[Male Enhancement Reviews]

The intentions of national ID system is good but we can't avoid that there is still somebody who might abuse it and put other peoples lives in jeopardy.

[Male Enhancement Reviews]

Thank your for sharing your review. Quality subject to dwell upon! Thanks!

[Acne treatment]

Isn't it bad to reduce citizens to a field of data ideally suited for the exercise of power in all spheres of their life?

[Viagra alternatives]

Great post, I hope you continue writing...

[i7 Laptops]

I have just learned about this website and Nana Glady's album--I am so thrilled!! I was blessed to hear Gladys when she first "appeared" on Ellen--She and Ellen just make me feel good--Hope they both "Just Keep On Keeping On"!!

[bossman585]

Fraud is just wrong..So not Cool, I hope it doesn't to me thank you guys for the info..

[Account Deleted]

good info about consensus and controversy

[best deals]

I was looking for crucial information on this subject. The information was important as I am about to launch my own portal. Thanks for providing a missing link in my business.

[Male Enhancement Reviews]

Nice posted article you've wrote to your readers like me. I would definitely bookmark this page to see more updates in the upcoming days.

[arizona weight loss]

Most diets fail when it comes to effective long-term weight loss - because they don't pay attention on the underlying causes of your weight problem.

[new balance]

Just wanted to say that you have some awesome content on your website. If it's OK I would like to use some of the information you provided on my webiste. If I link back to your website would it be OK to do so?

[male enhancement]

Is the NATIONAL ID SYSTEM the weapon against TERRORISM?

Of course not. It's a weapon against all freedom loving people. If you read the Declaration of Independence, the Articles of Confederation and Perpetual Union (which was never repealed or replaced) and your state constitution, you will see that you are the government. But some truly evil people have turned the tables on America, convincing us that they are the government.